Lord of the Rings Forum

Ian Holm will play the older version of Bilbo/nararator, and a few other people are being considered for the main role of Bilbo, including James Mc Avoy, Jack Black, Danial Radcliff, and Martin Freeman. they all look like quite good Bilbos... Shia La Boeff was mentioned a while ago, but I haven't h...

i love all the movies but i think i like the first one (extended editions!) more.

Saruman is my fave.

the link didn't work.

probably because the likes of me (an evil but cunning wizard) couldn't get into the pure woods of Lothlorien

from what ive heard, Ian Holm probably won't. he's too old. i heard that he's expected to narrate, which would be good, i guess

i'm not sure. i mean, PJ isn't going to be directing it, but Del Toro has made some great movies.

i think they did a great job with Gollum. very life like, and mangy and creepy and all that kind of good stuff

i'm a big fan of both book series' but i think that LOTR is better. Tolkien's life was totally dedicated to these books. he is really detail oriented to make every bit of LOTR come to life. While HP is a great book series, i think we need to wait a generation or two to see if it can really contend w...