Lord of the Rings Forum

Did Aragorn's ancestors secretly have connections to an ancient civilization predating even the Elves, potentially revealing a deeper and more mysterious history for the Line of Kings in Gondor? Explore the possibility of hidden lore that could challenge conventional understanding of Middle-Earth's ...

Could Tom Bombadil, a whimsical and enigmatic character in Middle-Earth, actually be an overlooked antagonist manipulating events behind the scenes, or is he simply a misunderstood and benign figure within the Lord of the Rings narrative? Explore the various theories and evidence surrounding Bombadi...

Imagine an alternate ending where Gollum triumphantly destroys the One Ring in the fires of Mount Doom. How would this unexpected outcome have reshaped the fate of Middle-Earth, its characters, and the subsequent events depicted in both the books and movies? Explore the potential consequences and in...

Who is the most divisive character in The Lord of the Rings series and why? Is it Boromir, Gollum, or someone else entirely? Share your thoughts and arguments based on their actions, development, and impact on the story. Let the debate begin!

Are there any hidden messages or symbolism in The Silmarillion that have yet to be discovered or discussed within the forum?