i am a fellow LOTR fan, just analysing my way through each movie cozi havnt got a life. I was just wondering why would the fellowship go to all that trouble of travelling through, Eragion-but realising Saruman was watching them, then to go over the misty mountains,-but Saruman ruin that idea too, then finally the trouble of Moria.
This could all have been avoided if they just travelled north over the misty mountains, north over the grey mountains, west of iron hills, westaround the sea of rhun. then just go through the giant oppening round the back end of modor. dress up like orcs and work there way through.
ps. i'm 45 and live with my mum does this mean i have no life?
Yes, there is always a lot of discussion on the Fellowship doing it differently, but then again, if the Fellowship had gone a different path, I'm pretty sure they would have had to face even more trouble and danger and that maybe... the ring might NEVER have been destroyed! :O
And all because of trying to find an EASY way out!!!!!
tut tut... you should be ashamed of yourself!!!!!!
Ok, i'm just kidding, but yeah. It's fine the way it happened, i mean, Gandalf the White wouldn't have come if they hadn't been so daring.
And to the person who started this topic, you are totally fine. You can be any age to love LOTR.
They were never in control, except for some respite such as after battles or the meeting at Rivendell. The ring was a strange adventure in the first place, because it had to be taken in the direction of the danger, rather than away from it. They could have left it for the ringwraiths and tried to save their own lives, but instead they wanted to destroy it.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests